Home
Blog
Radio
Missing Persons
Crime
May 05, 2024, 07:12:15 PM
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Login with username, password and session length
News
:
NEW CHILD BOARD CREATED IN THE POLITICAL SECTION FOR THE 2016 ELECTION
Home
Help
Login
Register
Scared Monkeys Discussion Forum
>
Current Events and Musings
>
Political Forum
> Topic:
Consumer Ripoff? H.R. 2382: Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009
Pages:
1
Go Down
« previous
next »
Print
Author
Topic: Consumer Ripoff? H.R. 2382: Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009 (Read 3463 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
WhiskeyGirl
Monkey All Star Jr.
Offline
Posts: 7754
Consumer Ripoff? H.R. 2382: Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009
«
on:
October 10, 2009, 08:17:18 AM »
H.R. 2382: Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009
I happened to catch CSPAN the other day for part of this debate. I really didn't know what an interchange fee was. I was shocked when I did a little research. It's almost like a hidden tax for the goods and services folks buy using a credit card. It makes it harder for small local businesses to compete and stay in business.
What happened to the change that was going to be for the little people? Responsible regulation?
I look at the fallout from the the first round of Consumer Protection legislation (anxious friends and family) that passed earlier this year and wonder
how is this protection?
Was the earlier bill written by the banks? Unlimited interest, fees, payments... The only thing consumer oriented seemed to be that the banks had to tell you of changes. I don't think it's working to benefit consumers.
What did work?
From memory, in the olden days, STATES regulated the maximum interest rate banks could charge for credit cards, late payments, interest on loans, etc. There was an incentive to only offer credit to people who had the capacity to pay back the money they borrowed. There was NO TAXPAYER bailouts or guarantees.
Banks make oodles on Obama Consumer protection legislation, consumers get the shaft - my opinion. Someone who may have been able to pay say $400 a month now gets a bill for over $1,200. What to do? Not a lot of options for everyone.
No protection I can see, just banks starting to look like good old fashioned loan sharks.
Interbank Fee reform and fairness.
Apparently, some folks in the House would like to regulate these fees and make the cost of credit available to consumers.
Here is a brief description of the bill "To amend the Truth in Lending Act to prohibit unfair practices in electronic payment system networks, and for other purposes."
Read the bill here -
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill=h111-2382
It seems like the merchants on Main Street may get the shaft when folks use their card for petty things.
"Vt. Retailers: Credit Card "Swipe Fees" Can Wipe Out Profits"
Quote
"The other day we had somebody swipe their card for a 35 cent pack of gum," store owner Warren Miller said. "Well, the credit card company made 21 cents on that transaction. We lost 7 cents on the transaction."
And those fees add up, especially as more people use plastic instead of cash. When the Millers bought the store 26 years ago, Warren says he had one or two credit card transactions a month. Now, they account for about 40 percent of his sales every day.
"Our credit card sales have gone up 52 percent in three years and our swipe fees have gone up accordingly. Our fees are between $3000 and $4000 a month," he said. "It's huge. Our power bill is $1000 a month. Our taxes are $1000 a month, so it's big."
http://www.wcax.com/Global/story.asp?S=11288608#
It looks like another hidden banking tax on consumers. Any of this money going to pay back the national debt?
There was a smirky politician who used the example of buying his daughters birthday cake - the bakery only accepted cash. Suggestions the merchants should just stop accepting credit. In my mind, a business selling a once a year item like a birthday cake is different from the place that sells groceries, gas, and other products that folks use every day.
The merchants are forbidden to offer a discount for cash paying customers, or charging the difference those who use credit.
I'm not sure a merchant has any idea HOW MUCH a consumer's credit card will scalp off the top of the transaction. Apparently, all that cash back and rewards are paid for through these fees. Could a merchant lose 2%? 5%?
Why shouldn't consumers know and pay for the price of the credit they use?
It seems reasonable to me that if they pay cash they should get the best price. If you want to use a card that takes 5%, they maybe should should pay that adjusted 5% above the cash price.
Hmmm...you didn't get a 5%, or even a 3% raise this year, but the bank did...
How much does the price of credit add to everyone's market basket? It seems like those paying cash are paying the price of credit to.
Another point -
about 80% of these interbank fees go to just 10 large banks
, many of which apparently were TARP recipients.
Mr. Smirky asked Mallory Duncan (of a retail organization, giving testimony) if anything prevented him or others from setting up a new card or interbank.
How
would Mr. Duncan be an expert?
I can think of a lot of things.
I would relate this to the old Ma Bell, before the breakup.
Lots of laws preventing anyone from competing, or selling phone products.
Even after the breakup, how many start-ups could put up competing phone lines?
Build their own interstate/international network? Ma Bell got a lot of government support in the early days to grease the wheels of progress.
Here is the testimony of Mallory Duncan from 2007 for a similar bill -
http://www.unfaircreditcardfees.com/uploads/Mallory_Duncan_Written_71907.pdf
"The collective setting of interchange fees by Visa and MasterCard represents an on-going antitrust violation and it costs merchants and their customers—that is, America’s consumers—tens of billions of dollars annually.
These fees, hidden from consumers, are in addition to the late fees, over-the-limit fees, and other card fees with which consumers are only too familiar.
This Task Force has an important perspective on this issue. The problems with interchange fees stem from basic antitrust law and competition policy issues with which this Committee is familiar. We hope that this hearing will be the first step in a thorough exploration of these issues by the Task Force."
Mr. Smirky asked why they don't pursue more antitrust violations through the courts.
Answer? It takes YEARS. How do you fix a violation that happened over the past twenty years? Why not fix the problem going forward?
"Visa and MasterCard are able to get away with this, however, because they have market power – both individually and jointly according to the courts.
By a very conservative estimate, Visa and MasterCard together control more than eighty percent of the credit card market.
The vast majority of merchants therefore have no choice but to accept their cards.
In fact, a recent study by the Kansas City Federal Reserve Bank concludes that merchants realistically cannot refuse to accept Visa and MasterCard payment cards, regardless of interchange fee costs."
I wonder how many of these banks got TARP money?
Quote
“There is an arms race to create cards with higher fees and more bells and whistles,”
NRF Senior Vice President and General Counsel Mallory Duncan said.
“The market checks that would normally exist to curb this escalation in fees are diminished because the card companies know that every merchant is required to take these expensive new cards or lose their ability to accept any cards.
The Welch-Shuster bill would allow the most expensive cards to be refused, and while we expect that few merchants would actually refuse cards if this were passed, it would make the card companies think before they reflexively introduce cards with higher fees.”
Quote
“Most consumers don’t know it, but every time they swipe a rewards card with its miles and concierge services, they are driving up the price of everything they buy even higher,”
Duncan said.
“This particularly hurts less-privileged Americans who don’t have rewards cards or can’t get cards at all because Visa and MasterCard rules effectively require that everyone pay the credit card price even if they are paying with cash, check, debit card or even food stamps.”
http://www.pr-inside.com/nrf-testifies-that-credit-card-companies-r1518875.htm
Why isn't the banking system working for Main Street?
Wow, what a deal. The more we use plastic, even debit cards, the more the banks make. To big to fail!!!
How many of these 'to big to fail' big banks outsourced their backoffice and IT functions to places like India?
Do any of these banks benefits Americans? They make wealth for a few, provide jobs to foreign countries, and get bailouts from taxpayers. What value do they add to the American way of life?
Taxpayers are getting the shaft.
my opinions.
Logged
All my posts are just my humble opinions. Please take with a grain of salt.
It doesn't do any good to hate anyone,
they'll end up in your family anyway...
WhiskeyGirl
Monkey All Star Jr.
Offline
Posts: 7754
Re: Consumer Ripoff? H.R. 2382: Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009
«
Reply #1 on:
October 10, 2009, 08:26:56 AM »
Another point I looked up, the position of Ann Duplessis of Liberty Bank in New Orleans, representing the "Independent Community Bankers of America"
According to OpenSecrets blog, this organization, in total lobbying income -
2006 $1,563,118
2007 $3,428,985
2008 $4,210,000
2009 $2,540,000 (not complete)
from this site
http://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/firmsum.php?lname=Independent+Community+Bankers+of+America&year=2009#
That's a lot of money. A drop in the bucket for bankers, a dream denied to those on Main Street.
jmho
Logged
All my posts are just my humble opinions. Please take with a grain of salt.
It doesn't do any good to hate anyone,
they'll end up in your family anyway...
WhiskeyGirl
Monkey All Star Jr.
Offline
Posts: 7754
Re: Consumer Ripoff? H.R. 2382: Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009
«
Reply #2 on:
October 10, 2009, 08:35:30 AM »
Quote
Visa issued a press release Thursday morning saying its average interchange rate is 1.62% of the sale, and hasn’t changed for a decade.
“Unfortunately H.R. 2382 is nothing more than a renewed effort by lobbyists representing some national retailers and trade associations to shift the normal cost of business onto consumers, while retailers continue to reap the benefits electronic payments offer and pad their profits,”
Visa's statement said.
There is an easy way to get the best price for consumers - a base price for cash, and a separate, variable price for credit.
I recall that the big warehouse clubs used to have a base price plus maybe 2% for the basic membership. Premium memberships just paid the base price.
If consumers can understand that, why not a base price, plus an additional amount to cover the merchant cost of using credit?
Quote
At least two other interchange bills also are pending in Congress. Convenience-store giant 7-Eleven last week presented petitions with nearly 1.7 million customer signatures asking Congress to regulate interchange (Digital Transactions News, Sept. 30).
I wonder how the interchange charges squeeze the small family owned 7-Eleven businesses?
http://www.digitaltransactions.net/newsstory.cfm?newsid=2342
Logged
All my posts are just my humble opinions. Please take with a grain of salt.
It doesn't do any good to hate anyone,
they'll end up in your family anyway...
WhiskeyGirl
Monkey All Star Jr.
Offline
Posts: 7754
Re: Consumer Ripoff? H.R. 2382: Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009
«
Reply #3 on:
October 10, 2009, 08:50:16 AM »
What do other global consumers pay for swipe fees?
Quote
Duncan spoke during a press conference held by the Merchants Payments Coalition to release its 14-page report, entitled,
“’Swipe Fee’ Reform--International Lessons.”
The MPC, also based in Washington, was formed by retail trade groups in 2005 to lobby in favor of interchange regulation. In the report,
the MPC shows the U.S. with the highest interchange among 15 countries or regions compared, at 2%.
New Zealand, Australia, and the European Union, all of which have acted to regulate interchange in one way or another, are shown at 0.95%, 0.50%, and 0.30%, respectively.
Quote
...the MPC says that consumers in the U.S. would have saved $125 billion over the past four years had the same regulation been imposed here as was imposed in Australia. In
2003, the Reserve Bank of Australia capped interchange at an average of 0.55%, about half what it had been.
“The result is consumers [in Australia] have saved money in the billions of dollars, there’s more competition, consumers pay lower fees for credit cards, and the economy has benefited,
all while credit card transactions have gone up,” said Douglas Kantor, counsel to the MPC, during the press conference.
Why aren't lower fees good for the American economy? Who do higher fees benefit? Banks? TARP recipients? Taxpayers?
http://www.digitaltransactions.net/newsstory.cfm?newsid=2324
Why do American businesses pay more? Why don't Americans pay say .3%?
Should Americans know how much credit costs them directly and indirectly? Should they be allowed to compare rates? Save more by paying cash?
Logged
All my posts are just my humble opinions. Please take with a grain of salt.
It doesn't do any good to hate anyone,
they'll end up in your family anyway...
WhiskeyGirl
Monkey All Star Jr.
Offline
Posts: 7754
Re: Consumer Ripoff? H.R. 2382: Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009
«
Reply #4 on:
October 10, 2009, 08:58:18 AM »
Quote
How much do interchange fees cost?
$48 billion a year, according to the Merchant Payments Association, a coalition of mostly retail trade associations lobbying to restrict the fees. How much do merchants pay? To put that in perspective,
Home Depot pays more in interchange fees than for employee health care.
Some of those costs get passed on to consumers.
http://www.businessweek.com/smallbiz/running_small_business/archives/2009/10/merchants_seek.html
Maybe there is a way to pay for healthcare in this nugget.
Logged
All my posts are just my humble opinions. Please take with a grain of salt.
It doesn't do any good to hate anyone,
they'll end up in your family anyway...
WhiskeyGirl
Monkey All Star Jr.
Offline
Posts: 7754
Mr. President, it's not just the SPENDING & DEBT!!!
«
Reply #5 on:
January 27, 2010, 05:21:01 AM »
It's not just the spending and debt, it's the little things that kill Main Street.
Why doesn't small business pay a fair fee? It seems like other nations look out for their small businesses, but for some reason, Washington and the White House look out for bank profits.
Sure, Obama wants a small tax on loans...
Why not give small business a break?
Just a few banks control all these networks. In the olden days, just Ma Bell controlled your phone. There was no innovation.
Why not let everyone compete?
Why not lower the amount skimmed off the top of every transaction? Transaction fees that kill Main Street and taxpayers? Stifles competition?
Logged
All my posts are just my humble opinions. Please take with a grain of salt.
It doesn't do any good to hate anyone,
they'll end up in your family anyway...
klaasend
Administrator
Monkey Mega Star
Offline
Posts: 74276
Re: Consumer Ripoff? H.R. 2382: Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009
«
Reply #6 on:
January 27, 2010, 11:40:22 PM »
It appears Obama wants to give small business a break afterall
Logged
WhiskeyGirl
Monkey All Star Jr.
Offline
Posts: 7754
Re: Consumer Ripoff? H.R. 2382: Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009
«
Reply #7 on:
January 29, 2010, 07:26:41 AM »
Quote from: klaasend on January 27, 2010, 11:40:22 PM
It appears Obama wants to give small business a break afterall
I don't think it's a break for small business. When I read up on these articles, big businesses, big retails get very low fees, while small business can be charged anything. I do not recall a limit.
I watched some of this on CSPAN. Small business can be charged 8% or more for the same transaction. That's hard on businesses that only make a 2% profit.
It cost them more to accept credit and debit cards. I remember some merchants telling them they get charged 8% and have to sign agreements with credit card machine vendors not to disclose how much the fees are to consumers, not to charge more for credit, or less for cash.
I'm not sure the Obama Consumer bill protects the consumer or ensures the profits of big banks.
Why not break up the monopoly the few big banks have on the transfer fees? Give access to the little community banks?
This was done to Ma Bell many years ago. Today, we have lots of innovation and cheaper rates for long distance calling and many other phone / data related services.
Logged
All my posts are just my humble opinions. Please take with a grain of salt.
It doesn't do any good to hate anyone,
they'll end up in your family anyway...
Pages:
1
Go Up
Print
Scared Monkeys Discussion Forum
>
Current Events and Musings
>
Political Forum
> Topic:
Consumer Ripoff? H.R. 2382: Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009
« previous
next »
Jump to:
Please select a destination:
-----------------------------
FORUM RULES
-----------------------------
=> Forum Rules and Tips
-----------------------------
Polls, Polls and more Polls
-----------------------------
=> Missing Persons Polls
=> Current Events/News Polls
=> Crime and Trial Polls
=> Just For Fun Polls
-----------------------------
Missing Persons - High Profile
-----------------------------
=> Missing Persons High Profile
===> Dylan Redwine, 13yrs old, last seen 11/19/12, Vallecito, CO
===> Kyron Horman - Portland Oregon
===> Caylee Marie Anthony - Florida (BODY FOUND)
=====> Caylee's Law - by State
=======> Caylee's Law - text
=======> ALABAMA
=======> ALASKA
=======> ARIZONA
=======> ARKANSAS
=======> CALIFORNIA
=======> COLORADO
=======> CONNECTICUT
=======> DELAWARE
=======> DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
=======> FLORIDA
=======> GEORGIA
=======> HAWAII
=======> IDAHO
=======> ILLINOIS
=======> INDIANA
=======> IOWA
=======> KANSAS
=======> KENTUCKY
=======> LOUISIANA
=======> MAINE
=======> MARYLAND
=======> MASSACHUSETTS
=======> MICHIGAN
=======> MINNESOTA
=======> MISSISSIPPI
=======> MISSOURI
=======> MONTANA
=======> NEBRASKA
=======> NEVADA
=======> NEW HAMPSHIRE
=======> NEW JERSEY
=======> NEW MEXICO
=======> NEW YORK
=======> NORTH CAROLINA
=======> NORTH DAKOTA
=======> OHIO
=======> OKLAHOMA
=======> OREGON
=======> PENNSYLVANIA
=======> PUERTO RICO
=======> RHODE ISLAND
=======> SOUTH CAROLINA
=======> SOUTH DAKOTA
=======> TENNESSEE
=======> TEXAS
=======> UTAH
=======> VERMONT
=======> VIRGINIA
=======> WASHINGTON
=======> WEST VIRGINIA
=======> WISCONSIN
=======> WYOMING
=====> Caylee Marie Anthony Murder Trial Archives
===> Sierra Lamar, 15yrs old, Morgan Hill, CA Missing Since March 16, 2012
===> JO ANN (JODIE) BAIN AND 3 DAUGHTERS MISSING 4/27/2012(2 murdered 2 safe)
===> Isabel Mercedes Celis, 6 yrs old missing 4/21/12 Tucson, AZ (Body Found)
===> Jennifer Kesse - Orlando/Ocoee, Florida
===> Susan Powell 28yrs old, missing 12/6/09 West Valley City, Utah
===> Michelle Loree Parker, Last Seen 11/17/11, Orlando, FL
===> Celina Cass, 11yrs old missing 7/25/11 New Hampshire
===> Aliayah Lunsford, 3yrs old, Weston, West VA, missing since 9/24/2011
===> Lisa Irwin, 10mo old missing since 10/4/2011 KC, MO
===> Robyn Gardner missing in Aruba August 2, 2011
=> Missing Persons - High Profile - Archives
-----------------------------
Virginia Area Missing and Murdered - possible connections
-----------------------------
=> Morgan Dana Harrington, 20yrs missing VA Tech 10/17/09(BODY FOUND)
=> Hannah Elizabeth Graham missing since 9/13/14 Charlottesville, VA
=> Alexis Murphy, missing since 8/3/13 Charlottesville, VA
=> Samantha Ann Clarke 19yrs. old Orange Va. Last seen 09/13/10
=> Dashad Sage Smith missing since 11/20/12 Charlottesville, VA
=> Cassandra Morton 23, Lynchburg, missing 10/10/09 body found 11/29/09
-----------------------------
High Profile Crimes and Trials (not missing persons)
-----------------------------
=> Jodi Arias trial - for the murder of Travis Alexander
=> Trial of George Zimmerman - 2nd Degree Murder of 17yr old Trayvon Martin
=> Scott Peterson Appeal of Murder Conviction
-----------------------------
Missing, Exploited and True Crime
-----------------------------
=> Missing Exploited and True Crime
===> Missing Persons Forum
=====> Missing Found or Presumed Deceased
=====> Missing Found Safe
=====> Missing Endangered Runaways
=====> Resourses, Search Groups and Fundraisers
===> Crimes Against Children, Elderly and the Disabled
===> Crimes of Passion/Anger
===> Serial Killers and Their Possible Victims
===> Unsolved Crimes
=====> Finally Solved
===> Haleigh Marie Cummings - Florida
===> Adji Desir - Florida
===> Somer Renee Thompson 7 yo, Orange Park FL 10/19/09(BODY FOUND)
===> Tracy Ocasio - Orlando/Ocoee, Florida
===> Shaniya Nicole Davis, 5 Fayetteville, NC Missing 11/10/09(BODY FOUND)
===> Holly Bobo, 20yrs old missing Parsons, TN 4/13/11
===> Hailey Dunn - 13yrs old - Colorado City, TX missing 12/27/10 (Body Found)
===> Elizabeth Olten - 9yrs, Jefferson City, MO missing 10/21/09 (BODY FOUND)
===> Lindsey Baum - McCleary, WA 6/26/09
===> Amber Leeanne Dubois 14yrs old - Escondido, CA(BODY FOUND)
===> Chelsea King, 17, Missing 2-25-2010 Rancho Bernadino CA (BODY FOUND)
===> Sandra Cantu, 8 years old - Tracy, CA(BODY FOUND)
===> Madeleine McCann - Portugal
===> Christine Marie Sheddy - missing since 11/13/2007 - Maryland(BODY FOUND)
===> Nevaeh Amyah Buchanan 5yr Monroe Michigan(BODY FOUND)
===> Gabriel Johnson 8 mo., last seen 12/26/09 Tempe AZ-San Antonio TX
===> Stacy Ann Peterson missing & Kathleen Savio murdered - Illinois
===> Zahra Clare Baker - 10yrs old Hickory, NC (Body Found)
-----------------------------
Natalee Holloway
-----------------------------
=> Natalee Holloway
=> Important Case Documents
===> Joran Statements/PV's
===> Paulus Statements/PV's
===> Deepak Statements/PV's
===> Satish Statements/PV's
===> Misc Statements/PV's
=> LCD Archive
=> Shango/Simian and other Codetalkers
-----------------------------
Current Events and Musings
-----------------------------
=> Monkey Musings / Open Discussion
=> Pop Culture Main
===> Hugely Popular TV Shows
===> Movies and Television
===> Social Media
===> Music
===> Books
===> Scared Monkeys Radio with Dana Pretzer
=> Health and Medical Issues
=> Food and Product Recalls
=> News of the Day
=> Business News
=> Sports
=> Political Forum
=> Religion (discussion and debate)
-----------------------------
The Monkey Lounge
-----------------------------
=> The Monkey Lounge
===> Fashion & Decorating
===> What's Cooking? Recipes
===> Games
=> Inspirational
===> Memorial - Gone but Never Forgotten
===> Gratefulness - Light a Candle in Prayer
===> Inspirational scriptures, songs, stories and prayers
-----------------------------
Natalee Discussions (2005 ARCHIVE)
-----------------------------
=> Natalee Holloway
=> Theory and Speculation
=> Links and References Only
=> Natalee Breaking News Archive
-----------------------------
General Discussions (2005 ARCHIVE)
-----------------------------
=> News Issues
=> Chit Chat
Loading...