Lively Case Discussion #633 6/2 - 6/3/2007

[yapperz1]

We have been saying for 2 years now..there is a little truth in every lie.
What the Dr said makes sense to me too.

[robots]

she is in something

but i still say LAND

and i still say ABANDONED septic tank

easy to open, its quick and easily hidden

[San]

Tyler and Angie Thank you and Great Job.

[BTgirl]

While I try to be open to everyone's theories, what I've always come back to thinking is that something happened at the rocks, she died either there or in Deepak's car, and she was put in the ocean in the fish trap.

Dr. Hodges theory doesn't include anything to do with the rocks, but it does make sense to me.

[klaasend]

I was lost on his "container" profiling but I agree about Joran.  I also agree it's most likely she is in the ocean now.

As far as the Deepak emails go, I do believe Deepak sent them.  The body of the email itself was most likely drafted by either Paul or Joran van der Sloot, IMO.

[Tibrogargan]

Apologizing now  for typos and ect. I could not keep up! Sorry  

thoughts ?

         

I think we are in the presence of many experts on Scared Monkeys.

Red, I think it is called life experience - you get an instinct that tells you when someone is lying.  The more extraneous details they add shows you what they are covering up.  Are we all amateur psychologists?

[Lala'sMom]

I was lost on his "container" profiling but I agree about Joran.  I also agree it's most likely she is in the ocean now.

As far as the Deepak emails go, I do believe Deepak sent them.  The body of the email itself was most likely drafted by either Paul or Joran van der Sloot, IMO.

What makes you think that?  Just curious..

[yapperz1]

Klaas I agree with you that Deepak sent the email but it was most likely for the most part drafted by Paulypuss or Joran to help establish an alibi or their story of the occurrences of that night.

[bleachedblack]

I agree yapperz, just as I feel there is alot of truth to the layered voice analysis and lie detector exams. the unconscious mind in something like an email likely hold alot of truth ie container=ocean.

[Red]

Red
If I understood him correctly he claims to be in contact with Dave especially about this.  He said that Dave knew what he thought about it and I also think he said that Dave agreed with him.  Well, I know we havbe all come to the same conclusions...problem is we can't prove it. That's the frustrating part.

I am sure he has been in contact with Dave, thats not the point. WHEN?

We have been in contact with Dave and Beth since 6-7/05. I have never heard this guys name until very recently.

I have never seen this guy on TV, ever, prior to H&C.

The water searches that TES did in 2005, had nothing to do with this guy. TES was turned down a deep water search the day after Dave Holloway left Aruba. TES was already searching the water and asked for some help. Dompig declined.

[klaasend]

I was lost on his "container" profiling but I agree about Joran.  I also agree it's most likely she is in the ocean now.

As far as the Deepak emails go, I do believe Deepak sent them.  The body of the email itself was most likely drafted by either Paul or Joran van der Sloot, IMO.

What makes you think that?  Just curious..

Which part, lol ?

[Tibrogargan]

I know there will be people who will mock me, but what Dr. Hodges said made sense to me.

It makes sense to me too BT.  The subconscious mind is a very powerful thing and even in the worst of criminals they have an underlying wish to be found out and to have the guilt lifted.  It is their conscious mind that keeps the cover up in place and is aided by others that are involved around them keeping them under control.

[klaasend]

Klaas I agree with you that Deepak sent the email but it was most likely for the most part drafted by Paulypuss or Joran to help establish an alibi or their story of the occurrences of that night.

Yep, I just said the same thing  

[Easywriter]

There have been some real whack-o's attracted to this case and they have come up with some crazy, crazy stuff.  I don't understand this guy completely, but he didn't seem over the top crazy to me.

[Grande]

While I try to be open to everyone's theories, what I've always come back to thinking is that something happened at the rocks, she died either there or in Deepak's car, and she was put in the ocean in the fish trap.

Dr. Hodges theory doesn't include anything to do with the rocks, but it does make sense to me.

I have always felt that something significant happend at Arashi Beach.  There is no other explanation for Deepak's urinating statementS hence the alibi for being there out of his vehicle.

[BTgirl]

Will someone please remind me what Dr. Hodges first name is? TY

[bleachedblack]

Will someone please remind me what Dr. Hodges first name is? TY

Andrew

[Sam]

dropped at the holiday inn

robots translation = dropped "IN" to something

Dr. Hodges claims this is a reference to her being in a container.  I didn't quite understand it at the time, but now I see where he thinks that anytime Deepak says they were in something or went into a room or a car or left her at the HI is a subconscious way of saying she's "in" something.  I think.

See Lalas I knew you could do it. Just like the Shango Tango right?


Tyler and Angie thank you for transcribing.

[Red]

Will someone please remind me what Dr. Hodges first name is? TY

Andrew

[BTgirl]

Will someone please remind me what Dr. Hodges first name is? TY

Andrew

Thanks, BB