Lively Case Discussion #643 6/20 - 6/21/2007

[klaasend]

No doubt about who Carla thinks did it and what happened to Natalee.

[Dihannah1]

Didn't know Jossy worked with them either.  Wonder what his impression was of them.

Hey, we could have done this show!  Don't need psychic abilities..

Right Klaas,  hope they say something exciting.

I'm pretty open to this kind of stuff but I don't know about this.......

I am very skeptical about this stuff,  but I truly tried coming into this with an open mind.  I'm really struggling.  Any of us could have done this, I'm sure we know more than them.  I can only hope they do/say something to surprise me.  But not looking good so far  

[BTgirl]

I would guess I'm in the minority here, but the psychic seems genuine to me. She doesn't seem to just be putting on a show. I watch that Psychic Detectives series sometimes, and even the police admit that some psychics do come up with information that helps them solve crimes.

[Sleuth]

Now Carla is at the VDS residence..

[sb]

Bear in mind... Beth believes it went down at VDS house.

I wonder what she thinks about all that these people are saying.

[Dihannah1]

I would guess I'm in the minority here, but the psychic seems genuine to me. She doesn't seem to just be putting on a show. I watch that Psychic Detectives series sometimes, and even the police admit that some psychics do come up with information that helps them solve crimes.

I believe she 'feels' this and is genuine in her own mind.  But they admitted at the beginning to already know so much about the case.  It can be pshycologically, unconcience induced acting.

[San]

Carla meeting up with Patrick so he hopes to get her reaction to another hot spot.  They are at the Van der Sloots.  Carla said she doesn't think she was there.  Carla gets a flash and said Natalee was there a drunk in your system.  She said the drug was administered by the person who took your life.  She said yes.  She said he made me sick then he killed me.

They are back at the FH.  As much as she dreads this she has to experience what this is.  Carla is getting sick.  Just wandering and doesn't know where she is and can't feel her legs (Carla is feeling what Natalee was feeling).  She died on the beach.  SHe said it was suppose to be better than this it was suppose to be perfect.  Carla is crying and going back to the car.  She is overwhelmed.

[Marlee]

I would guess I'm in the minority here, but the psychic seems genuine to me. She doesn't seem to just be putting on a show. I watch that Psychic Detectives series sometimes, and even the police admit that some psychics do come up with information that helps them solve crimes.

I just saw Psychic Detectives on a commerical and my thought was that they seem to be much better.  Maybe its because we  know so much that it is just all too familiar.

[San]

They are flying over the FH.  There was a money transaction for people to keep quiet.  Someone of wealth and took over.

[Dihannah1]

I know the police do use psychics and the have helped.  But, I'm sorry, unless they actually solve this case, I'm skeptical.  This was taped in February.  Nothing solved yet, that we know about.

[Dana]

I know the police do use psychics and the have helped.  But, I'm sorry, unless they actually solve this case, I'm skeptical.  This was taped in February.  Nothing solved yet, that we know about.

exactly

[robots]

seems to me, they have it backwards

she died at the sloot house of horrors

then taken somewhere else

possibly a beech,, just not the BEECH at the HUTS

[Red]

So far it seems they've said everything we already know.  Hope they come up with something excitingly new.

UM, ya think ...

Yes we will have Carpe-Vision posted on FP.

Ahh..Very nice!!

Another round of psychics huh red? We know the first psychic said she spoke to Natalee and wrote down over a dozen pages of notes that she gave to the family. She was no help when they asked where NH was located.

Hmm ,,, that map looks like the one Klaas did,

[Dihannah1]

On a postive note.  This is keeping Natalee in the media and could be educating some people on the case.  So I'm willing to give it that!

[mrs. red]

Klass... is that YOUR map?

I am pretty skeptical myself.... they just lost me... I will never believe that Natalee liked him.....

[Red]

No doubt about who Carla thinks did it and what happened to Natalee.

Carla has been reading SM.

[sb]

Every single bit of info that has been posted here about this show is about stuff that is common knowledge to anyone who has follwed the case. These people came front-loaded with a scenario and theiy are describing it.

[Dihannah1]

Every single bit of info that has been posted here about this show is about stuff that is common knowledge to anyone who has follwed the case. These people came front-loaded with a scenario and theiy are describing it.

Hey, it's all about ratings!   It's T.V.!

I think SM should do a show of the real facts!  ALL of them!

[sb]

Has she even mentioned K2 at all?

[klaasend]

They haven't said anything we didn't already know or suspect.  They didn't have to play the show out this way though.