USE ME: RUMORS OF BREAKING NEWS 3

[waitingtoknow]

was it ever said that they all had sex with her?  Or was that just a scenerio that somebody had in the posts?

http://www.riehlworldview.com/carnivorous_conservative/2005/06/rumors_of_sex_a.html

This is one of Dan's entries for June 5. Don't know how accurate a recounting of the amigos' original story to police this is, but this is how Dan reported it.

[TTownMike]

I wish I could tell where you are saying sex with 3?

That's not what I'm saying. That's what that online Aruban newspaper said (and what Dan Riehl reported that they said).

So, is it on the riehl site where the erica post is?

[westcoastguy]

I wish I could tell where you are saying sex with 3?

TTown.....read the first paragraph in this link.........

http://www.riehlworldview.com/carnivorous_conservative/2005/06/rumors_of_sex_a.html

[friend of monkeys]

I wish I could tell where you are saying sex with 3?

That's not what I'm saying. That's what that online Aruban newspaper said (and what Dan Riehl reported that they said).

JUVENAL!!!
you r saving my sanity here
thanx

[waitingtoknow]

They did not have sex with Natalee. In the car Natalee told them that she hasn't seen the lighthouse of Aruba yet. So they took her there so she can see it. Natalee was pretty drunk! And fell asleep in the car. And it was in the car only where Natalee made out with Joran van der Sloot. But they never had sex with eachother! And neighter did the other 2 guys. These guys are very close friends of mine and tey are not capable of hurting a girl that way! Everyone who know these guys here are sooo sure that they did not hurt her and neighter had sex with her! They're just not that kind of people. I have talked with them... and I know when they're lying yes or no. I just know these 3 guys are innocents and there defenitly were NO love affair at all.....

Posted by: Erica | June 9, 2005 04:36 PM

[TTownMike]

Of course! Theres no reason not to believe them.

[Juvenal]

I'm sorry but the posts from the Riehl site have contained some errors. I like to compare what is being said on all these boards and I have found thet Dan's site is more prone to go out on a limb and to make interpretational errors. Many of his posts read like they went through the old circle-game routine of passing through 2 or 3 different recitations before getting to the posted version.

He had it for 100% fact today that a body was found and that the case was solved.

The ONLY people whose word I completely trust in all this are the Mountain Brook group.

I have to stick up for him here.

First of all, he reported what the Aruban newspaper said accurately. I wish it was still up so I could demonstrate this to you, but it's not.

Second, go back and read what he said today about the search site and a body. Read it carefully.

[Juvenal]

I wish I could tell where you are saying sex with 3?

That's not what I'm saying. That's what that online Aruban newspaper said (and what Dan Riehl reported that they said).

So, is it on the riehl site where the erica post is?

No. I don't know anything about an Erica post.

[TTownMike]

Thanks. Now I get it!

[Y'alls Psychic Detective]

They did not have sex with Natalee. In the car Natalee told them that she hasn't seen the lighthouse of Aruba yet. So they took her there so she can see it. Natalee was pretty drunk! And fell asleep in the car. And it was in the car only where Natalee made out with Joran van der Sloot. But they never had sex with eachother! And neighter did the other 2 guys. These guys are very close friends of mine and tey are not capable of hurting a girl that way! Everyone who know these guys here are sooo sure that they did not hurt her and neighter had sex with her! They're just not that kind of people. I have talked with them... and I know when they're lying yes or no. I just know these 3 guys are innocents and there defenitly were NO love affair at all.....

Posted by: Erica | June 9, 2005 04:36 PM

Note that if you click on Erica's name, there's her email address (at least the one she entered when she posted the message).  I'm not going to post it here, but it's beachgirl something at yahoo.  I did a google search, but didn't find anything with that address.  Anyone want to email her?  

[Juvenal]

They did not have sex with Natalee. In the car Natalee told them that she hasn't seen the lighthouse of Aruba yet. So they took her there so she can see it. Natalee was pretty drunk! And fell asleep in the car. And it was in the car only where Natalee made out with Joran van der Sloot. But they never had sex with eachother! And neighter did the other 2 guys. These guys are very close friends of mine and tey are not capable of hurting a girl that way! Everyone who know these guys here are sooo sure that they did not hurt her and neighter had sex with her! They're just not that kind of people. I have talked with them... and I know when they're lying yes or no. I just know these 3 guys are innocents and there defenitly were NO love affair at all.....

Posted by: Erica | June 9, 2005 04:36 PM

This person is telling you what Natalee said in the car that night?

[TTownMike]

I don't believe for 1 min that Nat got in that car with thse 3 and wanted to "see the lighthouse"!

[waitingtoknow]

hmmm there is a beachgirl on TA....but I guess that would be a common screen name....  I think I am going to pass on emailing her...It would be nice if she would come in and post her story and let us ask questions....lol

[TTownMike]

OK, so are we saying that these two quotes contradict?  Cause that what I'm seing.

[sb]

juvenal, what I was saying was that yes, he DOES quote accurately what he gets... HOWEVER, he is quoting wrong or shaky sources and making factual errors. Whatever source it was on the ground there in Aruba was telling him about a ironclad confession and a body being found etc. was wrong, but he ran with it. I know the guy is a pro journalist and I like what he does including his politics, but there are "reaches" in a lot of the stories he has given and he is getting them from elsewhere. He isn't so much the problem, his sources seem to be.

[waitingtoknow]

yes, according to her friends...the brothers

They did not have sex with Natalee. In the car Natalee told them that she hasn't seen the lighthouse of Aruba yet. So they took her there so she can see it. Natalee was pretty drunk! And fell asleep in the car. And it was in the car only where Natalee made out with Joran van der Sloot. But they never had sex with eachother! And neighter did the other 2 guys. These guys are very close friends of mine and tey are not capable of hurting a girl that way! Everyone who know these guys here are sooo sure that they did not hurt her and neighter had sex with her! They're just not that kind of people. I have talked with them... and I know when they're lying yes or no. I just know these 3 guys are innocents and there defenitly were NO love affair at all.....

Posted by: Erica | June 9, 2005 04:36 PM

This person is telling you what Natalee said in the car that night?

[friend of monkeys]

This person is telling you what Natalee said in the car that night?

r u pulling an all nighter here juvenale...

[Y'alls Psychic Detective]

I'm sorry but the posts from the Riehl site have contained some errors. I like to compare what is being said on all these boards and I have found thet Dan's site is more prone to go out on a limb and to make interpretational errors. Many of his posts read like they went through the old circle-game routine of passing through 2 or 3 different recitations before getting to the posted version.

He had it for 100% fact today that a body was found and that the case was solved.

The ONLY people whose word I completely trust in all this are the Mountain Brook group.

I have to stick up for him here.

First of all, he reported what the Aruban newspaper said accurately. I wish it was still up so I could demonstrate this to you, but it's not.

Second, go back and read what he said today about the search site and a body. Read it carefully.

But you do have to admit he's posted a lot of things that were in error.  I know he's getting info from a ton of sources and it's hard to sort the wheat from the chaff, but there have been too many things we know not to be true to take his reports as 100% accurate.

[Juvenal]

hmmm there is a beachgirl on TA....but I guess that would be a common screen name....  I think I am going to pass on emailing her...It would be nice if she would come in and post her story and let us ask questions....lol

I don't think "Erica" knows what was going on that car on that night. She has no way of knowing.

[TTownMike]

hmmm there is a beachgirl on TA....but I guess that would be a common screen name....  I think I am going to pass on emailing her...It would be nice if she would come in and post her story and let us ask questions....lol

I don't think "Erica" knows what was going on that car on that night. She has no way of knowing.

No she is blindly sticking up for a friend.