Lively Case Discussion #495 7/15

Quote from: "Shizaru"

Quote from: "Tylergal"

Did Lala's just come by to take my name and leave.

Shizaru, you have worked hard on this getting information. What do you (personally) think took place from the point the car left the parking lot at C&Cs?

You mean, what do I think ultimately happned?

I'm working on a long essay on that, but right now I think they went to the lighthouse/Arashi beach, not Joran's house. Joran made up going to his house as part of his story that 2K dropped him off there and drove off with her, and then just stuck with that detail because he didn't want to admit it was a lie, and to counter the idea that Natalee thought he was staying at the HI. I'm positive she was still alive when they left Arashi due to Deapak's oridinary computer activity only a few minutes later. From Arashi I think she was left alone with Joran somewhere on the M beach.

And from that point on I have three theories:

1) Joran killed her on the M beach, 2K had no further involvement after leaving her alone with Joran

2) Joran raped her on the beach, left her there going in and out of consciousness, and Deepak and/or Satish came back and killed her (if so, based on the computer records timeline Satish is actually a more likely killer than Deepak, Satish could have gone back and found Natalee as soon as 2:45 but Deepak couldn't have gotten there until 3:30)

3) Satish did return to the beach 10-15 minutes after Joran's 2:26 phone call to pick up Joran. Natalee either died before then while alone on the beach with Joran, or in the presence of both Joran and Satish. At some point during the 30 minutes after Satish's 2:40 return to the beach and before Joran's 3:15 computer login, Joran and Satish disposed of Natalee's body using Deepak's car.

I would like to see that.
.
.
...

k